Penetration Testing for Insurance Firms: Boost Security, Compliance & Trust

Penetration testing for insurance firms has become a necessity as the sector faces a 309% surge in cyberattacks in H1 2025, compared to H1 2024. Attackers are no longer just after sensitive policyholder data; they are increasingly focused on disrupting core operations and undermining customer trust.

• DDoS attacks spiked 350%, strategically timed to cripple services during claim processing and policy renewals.
• Vulnerability exploits grew 10X, targeting unpatched systems and weak functionalities in customer-facing web portals.
• 92% of insurance websites were hit by bots, abusing login flows and automating fraudulent claims submissions.

With insurers handling massive volumes of personal and financial data, the stakes could not be higher. This heightened threat landscape makes penetration testing a necessity, not a checkbox.

Why Insurance Firms Should Not Skip Pentesting

1. Business Logic Vulnerabilities in Insurance Workflows

Insurance platforms run highly specialized workflows, from premium calculations and claim approvals to broker dashboards and renewals. Attackers often target the logic rather than code, manipulating values, bypassing claim checks, or exploiting renewal processes. These vulnerabilities can lead to fraudulent claims, policy tampering, and financial losses that automated scanners rarely detect.

Where logic typically breaks

• Premium calculations: Parameter tampering of sum insured, tenure, zone, NCB, or rider flags to underpay.Rounding/float tricks to shave amounts (e.g., coupon + pro-rate interactions). Step skipping to bypass disclosures or medical questionnaire gates.
• Claims processing: Eligibility bypass by reordering steps, altering diagnosis codes, or replaying pre-auth tokens. Document workflow abuse (e.g., uploading alternate file types to dodge manual checks). Concurrency races to submit duplicate claims or change settlement amounts during adjustment.
• Policy renewals & endorsements: Grace-period abuse to revive lapsed policies without penalties. Unauthorized extensions by modifying start/end dates or backdating through time zone gaps. NCB carry-forward manipulation to retain discounts after claims.

In manual penetration testing, security experts:

• Map critical workflows (quotes, claims, renewals, broker dashboards) and tests them for logic abuse.
• Simulate real-world attacks like parameter tampering, token replay, and privilege escalation.
• Validate both UI and API layers to uncover client-side gaps.
• Provide impact-first reports with loss modeling and remediation steps.

With Indusface Pen Testing, certified experts perform deep, comprehensive testing to uncover even complex vulnerabilities across insurance workflows. Once identified, customers have the option to autonomously patch vulnerabilities instantly through SwyftComply on AppTrana WAAP.

Powered by AI, SwyftComply ensures faster remediation with zero false positives, giving you both immediate protection and a clean, zero vulnerability report for compliance.

2. API Security Testing for Claims, Brokers, and Aggregators

APIs are the backbone of digital insurance, powering claims apps, aggregators, broker dashboards, and policyholder portals. But APIs often expose shadow endpoints, weak authorization checks, or excessive data. Attackers exploit these vulnerabilities for credential stuffing, data exfiltration, or fraudulent claims abuse.

This makes API penetration testing essential to uncover vulnerabilities and to validate how real-world attackers could exploit business workflows.

What this means in practice:

• Discover undocumented APIs and weak endpoints.
• Test for Broken Object-Level Authorization (BOLA).
• Simulate mass data scraping and rate-limit bypass.
• Validate token integrity across partner and aggregator APIs.

Indusface goes beyond standard scanning by combining the API DAST Scanner with expert-led penetration testing.

The experts detect OWASP API Top 10 vulnerabilities from broken object-level authorization and excessive data exposure to business logic vulnerabilities that automated tools miss.

3. Data Protection and Compliance Testing

Insurance firms handle PII, financial records, and health data, all tightly regulated under HIPAA, GDPR, and PCI DSS and regional compliances such as IRDAI and SEBI. A single breach can cost insurers millions.

IBM’s 2025 Cost of a Data Breach Report pegs the average at $5.56M for financial services, with GDPR penalties reaching up to 4% of annual turnover. Beyond fines, insurers risk brand damage, customer churn, and regulatory scrutiny.

Penetration testing in insurance must prove that policyholder data, claims evidence, and partner integrations are handled securely and in line with regulatory expectations. It is not only a technical exercise. It should also produce regulator-ready evidence that risk owners, auditors, and compliance teams can use.

What this means in practice:

Encryption & Secure Transmission

Validate TLS 1.2 or 1.3 end-to-end across customer, agent, and partner channels. Enforce HSTS, strong ciphers, and perfect forward secrecy. Use mutual TLS for third-party APIs with TPAs, reinsurers, and aggregator portals. Add certificate pinning for mobile apps where feasible.

Data at Rest & Key Management

Test encryption and key management for data at rest. Require AES-256 or equivalent with managed KMS or HSM, enforce key rotation, separation of duties, and least-privilege key access for claims handlers and vendors. Confirm envelope encryption for data lakes, archives, and long-term storage.

PII & PHI Exfiltration Testing

Attempt PII and PHI exfiltration across insurance-specific surfaces. Target quote and proposal forms, first notice of loss submissions, document uploads (photos, medical records, invoices), agent and broker portals, customer self-service, webhooks, and policy document generation. Check for IDOR issues, policy number enumeration, and leakage via OCR or data-enrichment services. Verify that document redaction is irreversible.

Cloud Storage & Backup Security

Review cloud storage and object stores. For S3, Azure Blob, or GCS, block public ACLs, review bucket policies, object ownership, versioning, and replication. Test abuse of pre-signed URLs, long TTLs, and permissive CORS. Include backups and snapshots in scope.

Check backups and disaster recovery flows. Ensure encryption in transit and at rest, confirm that restore tests do not land sensitive data in weaker staging environments, and verify masking in non-production. Align retention with legal hold and regulatory timelines.

Payment Data & PCI DSS Compliance

Verify payment data handling. Confirm tokenization, segregation of cardholder data, and that PAN and CVV are never stored, keeping PCI DSS scope as small as possible.

Data Residency & Regulatory Mapping

Confirm data residency and segregation. Pin storage to approved regions, segregate personal data by jurisdiction, and validate partner data-sharing controls on outbound integrations.

Produce mapped, audit-ready evidence. Tie methods and findings to IRDAI guidance for India, and to SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA for health insurers, and GDPR for EU customers where applicable. Provide reproducible steps, logs, and screenshots that auditors can trace from control to evidence.

Indusface pen testers bring deep insurance domain expertise from engagements with several large carriers across life, health, and general lines. Findings flow straight into AppTrana SwyftComply, which many leading insurers already use to apply instant virtual patches, close exposures, and produce zero-vulnerability reports that keep teams audit-ready.

4. Bot and DDoS Attack Simulations

Insurance firms face 2.5X more bot attacks than other industries, from credential stuffing and quote scraping to automated claim fraud. Layered on top are volumetric and application-layer DDoS attacks, which cause downtime, SLA violations, and customer churn.

Penetration testing simulates these real-world attack scenarios to measure how resilient insurance platforms truly are. Experts:

• Emulate bot-driven abuse such as large-scale credential stuffing or automated claim submissions to test rate-limiting, CAPTCHA, and anomaly detection.
• Launch controlled DDoS simulations at both the network and application layers to identify thresholds, bottlenecks, and response gaps.
• Validate whether existing defenses such as WAF, bot management, and DDoS mitigation hold up under pressure.
• Provide clear recommendations to strengthen resilience and reduce the risk of service disruption or fraud.

5. Third-Party and Client-Side Security

Insurers rely heavily on brokers, aggregators, and client-side scripts for payments and KYC. These external touchpoints introduce risks like formjacking, malicious injections, or insecure broker APIs, all of which can compromise policyholder data. Regulators now hold insurers accountable for third-party risks, not just their own.

Penetration testing evaluates these extended ecosystems by:

• Testing broker and aggregator APIs for authorization gaps, shadow endpoints, and excessive data exposure.
• Assessing client-side scripts for vulnerabilities to formjacking, Magecart, and malicious injections.
• Validating third-party integrations such as payment gateways and KYC modules for insecure implementations.
• Providing actionable insights to strengthen contracts, monitoring, and security controls around external partners.

6. Continuous and Post-Change Penetration Testing

Insurance applications are constantly evolving, with new features, updates, and integrations. Regulators like PCI DSS, GDPR, RBI and IRDAI mandate regular VA/PT cycles and post-change pentests to prove vulnerabilities are closed and have not resurfaced.

Continuous penetration testing is essential for insurance applications that evolve with constant updates, new integrations, and feature releases. Indusface PTaaS enables this with expert-led penetration testing backed by its WAS platform, which combines DAST, malware, and infrastructure scanning powered by an AI-Crawler for faster and deeper coverage.

Each identified vulnerabilities undergoes revalidation testing to confirm closure, while seamless CI/CD integration ensures that every change is tested before it reaches production. This approach gives insurers continuous security assurance, faster compliance reporting, and the confidence to roll out new features without introducing risks.

Future-Proofing Insurance Security with Penetration Testing

Penetration testing is a business-critical investment for insurers to safeguard revenue, maintain trust, and thrive in a digital-first era.

Book a demo with Indusface Pen Testing experts today and see how continuous, hybrid (automation + human-led) penetration testing secures your business end-to-end.

Stay tuned for more relevant and interesting security articles. Follow Indusface on Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn.