The CISO’s Checklist: How to Evaluate an API Security Platform

API Security Evaluation Checklist [Excel file]

In the first half of 2025, APIs have emerged as the primary focus for attackers. Unlike traditional broad attacks on websites, threat actors are increasingly exploiting vulnerabilities and launching DDoS attacks on APIs, which are often harder to secure and manage at scale.

Key insights from the State of Application Security Report H1 2025:

• API attacks rose 104%, driven by both vulnerability exploitation and DDoS activity.
• Vulnerability attacks on APIs grew 13X, highlighting their growing risk.
• DDoS attacks on API hosts increased by 388% per site, showing attackers’ shift to more targeted disruptions.
• Targeted attacks blocked by positive security policies grew 12X, emphasizing the critical need for strict API security measures.

APIs are now the frontline of digital attacks, making robust API Protection essential for any organization. CISOs need a strategic approach to ensure APIs are fully protected against both known and emerging threats. This CISO-focused guide provides a structured evaluation checklist to identify, compare, and select an API security platform that aligns with enterprise-scale risk, compliance, and integration needs.

Why You Need a Dedicated API Security Solution

As APIs become the backbone of digital transformation, they also expand the attack surface in ways traditional tools cannot manage. Legacy Web Application Firewalls (WAFs) and API Gateways are not designed to handle the complexity of modern API threats. Legacy WAFs focus on blocking known web exploits like SQL injection or XSS but lack visibility into API logic and data flows, making them ineffective against vulnerabilities such as Broken Object Level Authorization (BOLA), mass assignment, and business logic abuse.

Similarly, API Gateways manage traffic, authentication, and static rate limiting but do not detect malicious patterns, token abuse, or multi-step attacks that exploit APIs’ logical vulnerabilities. As APIs become more interconnected and data-rich, these gaps leave organizations vulnerable to sophisticated exploits.

That is why businesses need a dedicated API security solution, one that provides continuous discovery, schema awareness, behavioral analytics, and real-time threat prevention. Such a solution does not just extend existing web security; it offers context-aware, AI-driven protection purpose-built to secure APIs across their entire lifecycle.

How to Evaluate an API Security Platform: Questions Every CISO Should Ask

APIs are the lifeblood of digital businesses, but they also open doors to potential threats. For CISOs, choosing the right API security platform can be daunting. Instead of getting lost in technical specs, focus on asking the right questions. Here is a checklist to help you make confident decisions.

1. Do We Have Full Visibility of All APIs?

Visibility is the foundation of API security; you cannot protect what you cannot see. Shadow APIs, forgotten endpoints, and zombie APIs are often the most vulnerable. A strong platform helps you discover and secure known APIs and hidden ones lurking in your network, cloud, and applications.

Ask:

• Does the platform continuously discover all APIs including internal, external, and third-party?
• Can it identify shadow APIs and zombie APIs that may introduce risk?
• Does it maintain a real-time inventory detailing data sensitivity and risk posture?
• Is it compliant with OpenAPI specification and detects drift between documentation and runtime behavior?

2. How Does the Platform Detect Anomalies?

Attackers often exploit normal-looking traffic.   Understanding how anomalies are detected ensures threats are caught before damage occurs.

Ask:

• Does it use behavioral analysis to detect unusual patterns, or rely only on known threat signatures?
• Can it correlate user activity across endpoints to identify potential abuse?

• Can it prevent OWASP API Top 10 threats, especially logic-based attacks like BOLA?
• Does it employ AI and machine learning to detect anomalous behavior and suspicious sequences?
• Is it capable of detecting data exfiltration and mass assignment attacks?
• Can it redact sensitive data exposure and trigger suitable alerts?

3. Can It Protect APIs Without Disrupting Business?

Security should enhance resilience, protect critical assets, and maintain seamless operations; not create bottlenecks or slow down your systems.

Ask:

• Does it support adaptive rate limiting to prevent misuse while keeping traffic flowing smoothly?
• Can it automatically adjust limits based on user behavior, geography, endpoint criticality, or time-of-day traffic patterns?
• Does it provide granular access controls, allowing critical APIs to remain available while restricting risky traffic?
• Can it prioritize business-critical endpoints without compromising protection on less critical ones?
• Does it maintain high availability and low latency, even during attack mitigation?

4. How Automated are the Security Policies?

Manual configuration is time-consuming and prone to error. Automation ensures consistent protection and reduces operational burden on your team.

Ask:

• Does the solution offer automated enforcement of positive security policies, learning normal API behavior and blocking anomalies?
• Can it handle routine updates, signature tuning, and policy adjustments without constant human intervention?
• Does it provide pre-built templates and industry-standard policy recommendations for faster deployment?
• Can it learn from historical traffic patterns to reduce false positives over time?
• Does it simplify compliance reporting, automatically logging policy enforcement for audits?

5. How Effective Is Bot and DDoS Protection?

APIs are prime targets for bots and automated attacks. In fact, DDoS attacks on API hosts have increased by 388% per host, showing attackers are shifting toward more targeted disruptions. Effective bot and DDoS protection keeps APIs functional and prevents attackers from exploiting vulnerabilities.

Ask:

• Can it identify suspicious bot activity in real time using device fingerprinting, anomaly detection, and behavioral analysis?
• Does it provide layered defenses, from alerts to automated blocking against DDoS, credential stuffing, scraping, and abuse attempts?
• Can it distinguish between good bots (like search engines, llm crawlers) and malicious bots, avoiding unnecessary disruption?
• Does it offer geo-blocking or dynamic challenge mechanisms for high-risk traffic?
• Can it scale dynamically to absorb high-volume attacks without affecting legitimate traffic?

6. How Are False Positives Managed?

Too many false alarms waste time and erode confidence. A solution that reduces noise allows your team to focus on real threats and critical issues.

Ask:

• Does the vendor/OEM actively monitor and minimize false positives?
• Is there a process for validating and fine-tuning rules before pushing them live?
• Can the system provide actionable insights rather than just alerts, so your team focuses on genuine threats?
• Does it allow feedback loops from security teams to improve detection accuracy over time?
• Can it prioritize alerts based on risk, helping teams respond faster to high-impact incidents?

7. What Level of Threat Coverage Does It Provide?

Comprehensive threat coverage ensures your APIs are protected against both current and evolving risks.

Ask:

• Does it protect against privilege abuse, API parameter tampering, and subtle business logic attacks?
• Can it cover emerging threats without relying solely on signatures, using AI or behavioral detection?
• Does it detect chained attacks that exploit multiple endpoints in sequence?
• Can it provide real-time visibility into attack attempts and detailed analytics for compliance reporting?
• Does it include proactive threat intelligence and defenses against zero-day attacks?

8. How Well Does It Support Shift-Left Integration and Developer Enablement?

Embedding security early reduces vulnerabilities in production. Integrating security early ensures vulnerabilities are caught before reaching production.

Ask:

• Does it integrate with CI/CD tools such as Jenkins, GitLab, or Azure DevOps?
• Is tooling support available for developers via platforms like Postman, Swagger, or OpenAPI?
• Does it automate security policy enforcement and compliance reporting aligned with NIST, OWASP, or ISO 27001 frameworks?
• Can developers run pre-deployment scans locally or in staging to catch vulnerabilities early?
• Does it provide developer-friendly dashboards with remediation guidance and risk insights?

9. How Efficient Is It Operationally, and How Well Does It Integrate with Your Ecosystem?

Efficiency and integration drive higher ROI and smoother operations. A well-integrated, efficient platform ensures strong protection with minimal operational friction.

Ask:

• Can it scale easily to handle high workloads without slowing performance?
• Are there ready integrations for SIEM and SOAR tools such as Splunk or QRadar?
• How much manual tuning does it need, and are managed services available?
• What is the total cost of ownership, including support and maintenance?
• Is 24/7 expert support and dedicated customer success included?
• Does it provide audit-ready compliance reports and real-time analytics dashboards?
• Can it support multi-tenant setups and continuous policy improvement through threat intelligence?

Why AppTrana for AI-Driven API Protection?

AppTrana delivers AI-powered API protection that intelligently adapts to evolving threats, keeping your APIs secure, compliant, and high-performing without slowing your business.

• AI-Driven Discovery & Classification: Automatically detects known, unknown, and shadow APIs while classifying them based on sensitivity and exposure.
• Behavioral Threat Detection: Uses machine learning and traffic pattern analysis to identify anomalies, business logic abuse, and zero-day exploits in real time.
• Adaptive Policy Enforcement: Continuously learns from traffic behavior to refine positive security models, minimize false positives, and optimize rule sets.
• Automated Rate Limiting & Bot Mitigation: Leverages AI to differentiate between legitimate users and malicious bots, dynamically adjusting thresholds to prevent API abuse and DDoS attacks.
• Risk-Based Prioritization: Assesses vulnerabilities by severity and business impact, helping teams focus on the most critical issues first.
• Operational Intelligence: Provides predictive insights, real-time dashboards, and audit ready reports to enhance visibility and reduce manual overhead.
• Instant Vulnerability Remediation with SwyftComply: Autonomously remediates vulnerabilities in real time, reducing exposure and operational overhead.
• Managed Expertise: Backed by a 24×7 managed security team that fine-tunes AI-driven defenses for zero false positives and maximum uptime.

With AppTrana, organizations gain fully managed, AI-powered API protection that continuously evolves to outsmart attackers, ensuring your security posture is as dynamic as your digital business.

Start a free trail now to explore how AppTrana secures your APIs.

Stay tuned for more relevant and interesting security articles. Follow Indusface on Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn.